How Trump and Sanders Became So Popular

 

 

 

 

2015 and 2016 have definitely not been the years of political elegance or any form of political correctness. Recently John Boehner called Ted Cruz “Lucifer in the flesh” and Trump proclaimed “”The only thing she’s got going is the fact that she’s a woman,” in regards to Hillary Clinton. A Sanders surrogate named Paul Song came out to allude to Hillary Clinton and others as “corporate Democratic whores” and Trump alluded to the paralyzed political columnist Charles Krauthammer by stating “Then I get called by a guy who can’t buy a pair of pants, I get called names?” Yet despite brash and outright offensive critiques, two polar opposite candidates are gaining traction with the frustrated American populous. One is a billionaire who distrusts the establishment in his own party and the other being the longest serving independent in Congressional history who rallies against the billionaire class on a daily basis. Yet these two polar opposites have somehow seized the limelight and energized previously disenfranchised citizens who have garnered little attention to their situation from Washington. Two individuals of opposite sides of the political spectrum have rallied around a plethora of similar messages, with different details. So how have these individuals garnered so much support? This can be answered in one simple word, frustration.

In the last 25-30 years the American economy has seen a swift increase in worker productivity and technological advancement. Yet the common American has felt left out of progress, with an economic ceiling blocking them from socio-economic advancement.The recent jobs report from the BLS show an increase of 215,000 employed Americans as the economy rests at full employment. Full employment being the most efficient utilization of resources without becoming inflationary, not meaning every American individual having a job. Since 2008 the American economy has made great strides as the Obama administration has created 14.4 million jobs along with 73 months of undisturbed private sector job growth, an economic record. The labor force participation rate has inched its way upward as of recent and in comparison to how other nations have handled vast financial crisis such as 2008 and 1929, the “United States has performed better than any large economy on Earth in modern history” in regards to economic recovery from the deepest recessions. According to the March jobs report, wages grew 2.3% this year which beat expectations. The deficit (not the national debt), is 1 trillion dollars lower than when Obama stepped into office and the deficit has been cut by 3/4th on average according to Andrew Ross Sorkin from the New York Times. However, average household income is still $4,000 less than at the end of the Clinton administration. According to the Center For American Progress, trickle-down economics has stagnated wages as average real hourly earnings fell at an annual rate of .1% between 1981 and when Clinton took office. In contrast, the Clinton administration was the last era of vast wage growth as average hourly earnings grew by 0.9 percent per year until Clinton left office. As seen in 2008, wages do naturally fall in recession as labor markets become more competitive as millions flock for job opportunities. However, while wages have risen as of late due to a recovered economy, the struggle is still felt by millions of middle class Americans. Both Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders are playing on this middle class frustration in order to garner populist support. Both insult these stagnate incomes and critique establishment economics which have left millions of Americans economically insecure. Sanders rallies around an Emmanuel Saenz study which shows the top 1% taking home on average 91% of pretax income. Sanders sees this as a result of a corrupt campaign finance system and the U.S. government being in bed with the wealthy elite as corporations pay ”starvation wages”. Sanders also blames income inequality on the decimation of unions in the American private sector workforce. Trump blames the United States campaign finance system and also attributes wage stagnation to an influx of undocumented immigrants working for lower wages, thus resulting in a race to the bottom. Both Sanders and Trump create a protectionist sentiment in regards to trade, seeing economic trade deals as drivers of American unemployment and a race to the bottom. Sanders and Trump both seize on the manufacturing sector as 2.7 million jobs have been lost to China, 2.1 million in the manufacturing sector according to U.S. News. Trump and Sanders see the Chinese as corrupt currency manipulators and wage manipulators who devalue their currency and lower wages below market value dishonestly which has increased the U.S. trade deficit. While the two candidates fail to address the key economic benefits and gain laid upon the U.S. as a result of the WTO, CAFTA, NAFTA, and possibly the TPP, they still reiterate the same talking point of a middle class under siege. This message has resulted in huge American populist protectionism, which is economically uncompetitive and would stunt U.S. economic health, but sits well with a frustrated middle class. Both candidates have banked on American frustration regarding unemployment and wage stagnation as income inequality has increased, which sits well with the typical middle class American blue collar worker.

Donald Trump recently exclaimed in response to the RNC that “The system is corrupt.” and “What they’re trying to do is subvert the movement with crooked shenanigans.” Trump stated this soon after Cruz swept Colorado’s 37 delegates due to the state not holding a popular vote. After the DNC withheld crucial voter date from Bernie Sanders, the Sanders campaign followed through with a lawsuit. Sanders has even publicly proclaimed “Very little is going to be done to transform our economy… unless we end a corrupt campaign finance system which is undermining American democracy.” Both candidates have seized the opportunity to cast critiques on the many loopholes in our campaign finance system. Buckley v. Valeo put stark limits on direct campaign contributions yet allowed for candidates to put in unlimited sums of personal money into their own campaigns. In Citizens United v. FEC, the United States District Court of D.C. had its decision reversed by the United States Supreme Court which has allowed for Super PAC’s to raise money and spend unlimited independent expenditures as long as the spending was “independent” of candidates. PAC’s however have a $5,000 campaign contribution limit or can give a capped $15,000 to any national party committee according to OpenSecrets.org. While Super PAC’s may not have direct contact with candidates, these Super PAC’s can run ads and campaign in favor of a certain candidate or may critique other candidates as long as direct contact is not made with an official campaign. Both Trump and Sander’s understand that in return for helping candidates in elections, these interest groups earn favor and receive legislative, executive, and judicial gifts from those who they helped get elected. This is best seen in a recent report that states, for every dollar a top 50 corporation pays in taxes, they receive $27 back in corporate welfare. Every dollar a top 50 corporation uses for lobbying results in $130 in tax breaks and credits and $4,000 in corporate welfare. Bernie Sanders has called this “crony capitalism” or “socialism for the rich.” Donald Trump has been seen as an “anti-corporate candidate”, even if his actions as a real estate mogul speak differently. In response, the Sanders campaign has ran a grass roots campaign for the people and raised $44 million in March, thus leading to a total of near $109 million in the first quarter of this year. The Sanders campaign has touted its average annual campaign contribution of $27 and has criticized Clinton’s fundraising methods of Wall Street donations and a recent campaign fundraiser for Clinton by George Clooney which had tickets cost around $33,400 at minimum and $353,400 at maximum. In response, Sanders supporters stood outside Clinton’s motorcade and threw dollar bills at the moving vehicle in protest. Sanders has rallied around the idea that individuals such as the Koch Brothers have access to legislators unlike the American common man. Donald Trump has also reached into his own pocket and accepted small campaign donations in protest of campaign finance corruption. Trump has spent $17.8 million of his own money on his campaign which makes up the majority of the $26 million he has brought in. Trump has chastised his fellow party member’s connection to big money interest and has become a wild card in regards to campaign finance reform. Both the Brooklyn made Senator and the Manhattan real estate mogul have banked off American frustration with the political process and have promised to return democracy to the common American populous.

Donald Trump has continuously promised to “Make America Great Again” and Sanders has promised to “Revitalize the American Middle Class”. Both individuals in the end have promised to rebuild America. For instance both individuals see our crumbling infrastructure as a disgrace. Bernie Sanders has promised to invest $1 trillion dollars in roads, bridges, water, and rail systems which he states could uphold 13.5 million new middle class jobs. On September 3rd of 2015, Donald Trump echoed this sentiment by stating “We have infrastructure that we have to fix, we have bridges and roads and tunnels and everything’s falling apart.” Both candidates have expressed sentiment for rebuilding America from the inside out. Both Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders have promised not to cut or eliminate Social Security or Medicare, both programs supported by millions of Americans. Sanders has criticized the war in Iraq along with Trump despite Trump typically being more hawkish than Sanders. Trump has flip flopped on past foreign policy ideas, yet as of recent has stuck to his core message of rebuilding the U.S. military.

Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders both have stark contrast yet share a variety of core concepts they wish to achieve if ever elected into the highest rank in the land. Both candidates do have many differences in regards to immigration, taxes, and other key policy areas. Yet both these individuals do share the basic core economic and political critique of the past 30 to 40 years. The candidates have united a movement in Middle Class America centered on frustration. Increasing economic inequality, stagnant wages, and limited prosperity have been key issues addressed in both campaigns along with political corruption. Donald Trump has played on the fear of social change and socio economic hysteria while Sanders has utilized the critique of the wealthiest Americans and “crony capitalism.” While both candidates have different reasoning for these issues, the message can be felt by the common American. Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders have both in their own ways created two political movements of angry constituents who wish to return America to greatness and shared prosperity. While both candidates play on similar concepts irritating the common American, the reasoning behind the issues at hand are open to millions of Americans own philosophical interpretation. The fact of the matter is, the American populous is frustrated and in response have shifted their political leanings further right and further left in order to disrupt the current political order they deem unfit to govern.

 

Written by Dylan Lofton a centrist Democrat

 

 

 

Taxes and Economic Correlation

A Critque of Conservative Economics

Dylan Lofton

Taxes, the nuisance that all individuals wish to avoid as W-2’s come in the mail reminding them that they are one step closer to taking a few hours of free time to file taxes. As Americans, we typically fear the idea of a big government. We imagine bureaucrats in white suits roaming around with tax payer dollars in hand and packing their particular agencies pocket. Due to this image, we typically favor the idea of tax cuts as a way to lead to economic growth. The traditional economic argument goes as follows, “a decrease in personal income taxes leads to an increase in disposable income. This upholds consumption which increases aggregate demand” Another argument regarding business taxes goes as follows, ” A decrease in business taxes leads a decrease in per unit production cost, thus increasing aggregate supply”. Economics is not an absolute science, so what if I told you that this comfortable ideology has it’s flaws?

 

Corporate Taxes

 

How many times have we been told that cutting corporate tax rates will lead to increased investment in the United States economy and labor force? Yet this ideology has a plethora of flaws that conservative economists have failed to account for. We have been told that on average we pay the highest statutory rate out of all OECD countries, a whopping 39.1%. This is huge in comparison to the OECD average of 27.7%. However, once loopholes are taken into account the U.S. effective corporate tax rate is around  27.1 percent according to the Congressional Research Service, near par with the OECD average. In fact, out of the top 500 top cap companies, 115 paid less than 20% in corporate income tax rates and 39 of those companies paid a rate less than 10% from 2006-2011. We have been promised that lowering these rates would lead to reinvestment into the United States. However, when corporate tax rates were the highest at 52.8% the unemployment rate was a settle 3.5% as the economy was between full employment and inflationary. Yet from 1986 to 2011 the U.S. corporate income tax rate declined from 46% to 35% and the unemployment rate increased from 7% to 8.9%. In 2004, under the Bush administration, a tax holiday was announced in order for companies to reinvest in the United States. The corporate tax rate was reduced, yet the 15 corporations who benefited most cut a net 20,000 jobs. Bill Clinton went on to raise corporate tax rates, and the economy created a net 23 million jobs with the fastest income expansion since the 1960’s. This taxation spike did not cause the economic takeoff, but it did not plunge the economy into the depths of recession as conservative economists predicted. We actually see, according to The Center For American Progress, that investment during non-supply side era of the 1990’s outpaced that of both the 1980’s and 2000’s supply side eras. Average annual growth in non-residential fixed investment grew by 10.5% in the 1990’s Clinton era compared to 1.4% in the 1980’s and 6.7% in the 2000’s.The main contributor to economic growth and corporate job creation is demand, rather than taxation. A July 2011 survey interviewed 53 prominent U.S. economists, where 65% stated lack of demand was the main contributor to poor job creation, compared to only 27% who stated it was over-taxation. Corporations have the audacity to pay wages below market value which is the main contributor to a lack of demand, and then go on to deceive the American voter into thinking it is due to poor taxation methods? Corporations continue to promise economic prosperity in return for tax cuts, yet fail to reinvest in U.S. jobs when these tax rates are delivered. Once again, another basic economic theory proposed to the American people has come up short in promises and left American jobs eradicated. In the meantime, corporations continue to hold 2 trillion dollars in assets overseas promising to reinvest when tax rates are lowered, yet the promises of the past do not uphold to economic scrutiny.

 

Income Taxes

 

Many economists continue to persist in efforts to establish more flawed trickle down economic policy, even in the face of factual evidence eradicating the whole concept. We as Americans tend to favor personal income tax cuts for ourselves when in reality, it is sometimes not the best solution for economic growth. Personal income tax cuts for the poor and middle class can be beneficial depending on the current state of our marginal propensity to consume. However, when the wealthiest receive tax cuts we little to no correlation to the idea of trickledown theory providing an increase in overall income and economic growth. To critique this theory we must break its effects down into 3 critical assessments.

 

The first critical assessment to determine the economic growth is average income growth for all Americans. Reagan and many individuals promised a rising tide that would eventually lift the economic conditions of all. However, when under economic scrutiny, these theories fail to provide the truth. For instance, wages have fallen to a record low as a share of GDP. Wages have remained stagnant for the average American, thus actually reducing purchasing power in the economy. (See Sample 1). According to the Washington Post, until 1975 wages accounted for greater than 50% of our gross domestic product.  Yet after decades of trickle down policy, wages are now at record lows sitting at around only 43.5% of our GDP. However, the share of wages going to the top 1% has grown from 7.3% in 1979 to 12.9% in 2010. From 1973, worker productivity grew by around 80%, while wages grew at 1/8th the pace according to the EPI. Bush promised more trickle down economic when he entered office, yet real hourly pay has remained stagnant since 2000 even as productivity increased by 23%. In 1988, the income for the average American adjusted for inflation was around $33,400, yet the average income was just $33,000 in 2008 according to CNN. However, the top 1% of Americans have seen their income grow 33% over the last 20 years. Productivity grew 80% between 1979 and 2009, yet the hourly wage for the median worker only grew 10.1% which has not kept pace with the value of inflation according to the EPI. According to the EPI, between 1979 and 2012 the median worker has seen a wage increase of only 5% while productivity grew 74.5%. The 20th  percentile worker also saw a wage decline of .4%.  The Clinton administration did experience the fastest wage growth since the 1960’s, yet this was after trickle down policies were reversed. As a result of trickle down polices, we see that the top 1% captured 91% of market generated income (pre-tax) according to Emmanuel Saenz. This leaves the bottom 99% of Americans fighting for a minute 9% of total wealth in the U.S. According to the Center For American Progress, we find that when trickle down policies were reversed in the Clinton era, we saw average annual growth in real hourly earnings grow by 1% compared to -.5% in the 1980’s supply-side era. This average annual growth also remained flat at around 0% in the 2000’s supply side era.  Reagan and prominent conservative economists all proudly proclaimed that wealth would trickle down like a faucet. Yet, the American people are still left wondering if the government has even paid the water bill.

wages_1940-2010 Sample 1

 

The second critical assessment is comparing taxation policies to average growth in GDP and average annual employment growth. In regards to GDP, we find very little correlation to tax cuts for the wealthiest Americans and economic growth. (See Sample 2) Rather, what we see is almost directly the opposite. According to the Center For American Progress, the 1950’s was a period of high taxation with a top rate of 90%. During this period. Real annual growth averaged more than 4%, yet during the years of a 35% tax rate and lower growth has been half of that seen in the 1950’s. In years when the top marginal tax rate was lower than 39.6%, growth averaged 3.8%. Yet when rates were 39.6% or higher, growth averaged 3.8%. Growth in the years when tax rates averaged 50% or lower have seen an average yield of 2.7%, while the years with a tax rate higher than 50% have seen an average growth rate of 3.7%. The three taxation eras with the highest average in GDP growth go as follows: 75-80% (higher than 4.5%), 90% (around 4.1%) and after a tax increase to 39.6% (around 3.75% growth). Yet according to conservative economics, the trend should rather be in reverse with lower tax rates yielding higher average GDP growth. Bill Clinton raised the top rate to 39.6% and conservative economists, yet we see that our nation experienced the greatest economic expansion in history. I’m not stating that this tax rate hike created that economic development, but rather that it did not throw the economy into recession as Newt Gingrich and conservatives predicted.

marginal_tax_chartSample 2

 

In regards to average annual job growth, we see trickle down eras fail to deliver the promises of rampant job creation. (See Sample 3) In the last 60 years, job growth has been stronger in eras with higher marginal tax rates. According to the Center For American Progress, when the top rate was 90% average annual job growth totaled 2%, while the era of a 35% taxation rate only yielded a .4% increase in average employment growth. In order to avoid sweet spots and selective data, let’s look at this from a broader perspective. When the marginal tax rate was 50% or above, average annual employment growth totaled around 2.3%. In times with a rate below 50%, we see that average annual employment growth was only 1.15%, half of the growth seen with tax rates above 50%. The 3 eras of taxation with the highest average yields in employment growth are as follows: 75-80% (2.5% employment growth), 69-75% (slightly lower than 2.5%) and 39.6% after taxes were raised showed an average employment growth rate of above 2.25%. If all years since 1950 were ranked by overall job growth, the top 5 years would all contain a top rate of above 70%. Bill Clinton raised the top rate to 39.6% in the Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1993, yet the economy added a net 23 million jobs. If trickle down economic theory was correct, the trends seen in taxation and growth would be reversed. Instead, statistical evidence proves these theories once again to be incorrect.

job growthSample 3

If trickle-down economics has failed to provide growth in regards to income, Gross Domestic Product, and employment…. what has this theory really provided? Trickle-down economics has left the government short in regards to adequate revenue and has held hostage critical investments in education, green energy, and infrastructure. In 2000, George W. Bush was left with an 86.4 billion dollar surplus, excluding Social Security revenue, passed on from the Clinton administration. Within months, the surplus was gone as Bush spent an allocated 1.7 trillion on the war in Iraq and slashed taxes for the wealthiest Americans. Before we jump to far ahead, we must evaluate the root of this economic fallacy. During the early years of Reagan, the Laffer Curve began its rise to fame as it became common belief in conservative circles that tax cuts would actually increase revenue in the long run. However, during the years of Reagan we see this as inherently untrue. In 1981 Ronald Reagan reduced the top income tax rate from 70-50% and reduced the top capital gains rate from 28-20% as he passed the Economic Recovery Tax Act of 1981. Many applauded this move as they felt it promoted economic growth and cured inflation, when in reality the Federal Reserve curbed inflation, not Reagan. Yes, the Federal Reserve which is the epitome of centralized authority in economic planning which conservative economists continuously criticize. Stagflation was taking its toll, so the U.S. Federal Reserve tightened monetary policy in order to fight inflation. After inflation was cured, the unemployment rate could be reduced later down the road. Due to revenue shortfalls, Reagan backtracked in 1982 and signed TEFRA a series of short tax increases. TEFRA failed to close the current deficit so Reagan signed into law the Deficit Reduction Act of 1984 which increased the span of taxable corporate income and at that time was dubbed the “largest tax increase in U.S. history”. The actions of 1982 and 1984 halted the deficit due to increased taxation, but then came the Tax Reform Act of 1986. The TRA of 1986 reduced the top tax rate from 50-28%, reduced the corporate tax rate from 46-34%, and established a long term capital gains rate of 28%. Overall, Reagan cut the tax burden of the American people and we did see an increase in raw dollars going to the federal government as revenue. However, looks are deceiving as revenue always goes up in a recovering economy and as population growth increases tax receipts. In order to provide an accurate assessment of tax cuts and there effect on revenue, we must look at revenue as a percentage of GDP. The average amount of our GDP that revenue makes up is around 18.1%. When looking at Reagans tax legacy we see revenue always below the average of 18% of our GDP. (See Sample 4).The only time revenue greatly exceed that 18% threshold is in 1993 when Bill Clinton signed the Omnibus Reconciliation Act of 1993 into law, which raised the top bracket on income taxes and corporate tax rates. After the tax cuts of 2001, we once again see revenues plummet as a percentage of our GDP. As revenue falls we see an obvious increase in our national debt and deficit. We have seen the national debt increase 1.77 trillion under Reagan (190% increase) and 4.9 trillion under Bush (86% increase) according to FactCheck. We also see that Reagan had the debt ceiling increased 18 times (67% increase) which is a record for any administration. We also see that under Republican administrations the debt ceiling has been increased 49 times since 1960, compared to 30 times for the Democrats. So much for fiscal conservatism huh?

Do Tax Cuts Increase RevenuesSample 4

 

 

I can already hear many individuals complaining that we would not have the issues at hand if the government would simply cut its irresponsible spending. However, this is contractionary policy that is economic suicide in times of recession. Government spending is a main component of our Gross Domestic Product. GDP is composed of Consumption + Gross Private Investment + Government Spending + Net Exports. A decrease in government spending is in direct correlation with a decrease in economic output. For instance, stimulus spending from New Deal and emergency World War 2 polices cut unemployment from 25% to a low of 1.3%. Under FDR, there was a slight recession in 1937-1938 due to a halt in revenue being transferred from the reserves into economic spending. This recession happened as a result of FDR listening to fiscal hawks and reducing government spending at the wrong time. As soon as government spending was increased, the unemployment rate began to drop once again. Another example is the stimulus under Barack Obama, which according to the CBO, saved and created 1.3 to 3.5 million jobs that otherwise would not have been created without federal stimulus. (See Sample 5). This federal spending turned around GDP almost immediately. (See Sample 6). If you look into the rates of layoffs after the stimulus, they immediately decrease and private sector employment begins its return to normalcy. (See Sample 7). Many trickle down economists have critiqued Obama’s fiscal and economic record yet fail to adhere to factual evidence. According to the latest Department of Labor data we find that in February the economy added a net 242,000 jobs. This brings Obama’s total to 14.3 million jobs starting from early 2010 when his policies were first implemented. The President has set a record for 72 months of private sector job growth and incomes rose on average 2.2% in the last year. We have also seen a slight uptick in the Labor Force Participation Rate as of last year.At the same time, President Obama has reduced the deficit (not the national debt) by around 2/3 during his 2 terms. The truth is, conservative trickle-down economics is economic illiteracy sacrificed on an altar of misleading promises. When analyzed, trickle down policy fails to provide income growth for all Americans and fails to provide economic growth across the board. Trickle down policy also fails in comparison to administrations who have reversed its death spiral. The truth is, conservative economists have failed to understand what John Maynard Keynes really meant when he stated “The boom, not the slump, is the right time for austerity at the Treasury.” We must raise taxes on the wealthiest American’s and be fiscally responsible in times of economic boom, yet promote expansionary fiscal policy backed by revenue during the trough of recession.

stimulusSample 5

gdp_recov  Sample 6

stimulus and employment Sample 7

 

Conclusion

Americans since the beginning of Reagan have been lied to through the biggest Ponzi scheme in American economic history. Trickle down economics has failed to provide for the common welfare while at the same time not living up to the predictions of prosperity. It is time that the lies of conservative economics are revealed as what they truly are meant to accomplish, the entrenchment of wealthy Americans at the expense of the most vulnerable. Tax cuts for corporations and wealthy Americans have failed the basic tests of  analytic examination while throwing American society into the depths of economic despair. These policies have left the common American in disarray and in economic insecurity, while on the same token deceiving Americans by utilizing false ideologies sacrificed on an altar of flawed principle.

 

 

 

Sources

http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/statements/2014/sep/09/eric-bolling/does-us-have-highest-corporate-tax-rate-free-world/

http://corporatetax.procon.org/

 

http://bigstory.ap.org/article/65f4224f64e84b6ea4f516dca8de5e65/clinton-proposes-new-exit-tax-corporate-inversions

 

https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/tax-reform/news/2006/02/16/1844/bushs-tax-and-budget-policies-fail-to-promote-economic-growth/

https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/tax-reform/news/2011/06/27/9856/rich-peoples-taxes-have-little-to-do-with-job-creation/

 

 

http://www.businessinsider.com/us-budget-deficit-2011-7

 

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2011/jul/26/barack-obama/obama-says-reagan-raised-debt-ceiling-18-times-geo/

http://www.politifact.com/wisconsin/statements/2014/sep/05/barack-obama/obama-says-he-has-cut-national-deficit-half/

http://www.epi.org/publication/a-decade-of-flat-wages-the-key-barrier-to-shared-prosperity-and-a-rising-middle-class/

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/01/13/sunday-review/americas-productivity-climbs-but-wages-stagnate.html?_r=0

http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/apr/19/bernie-s/bernie-sanders-says-99-percent-new-income-going-to/

http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0104719.html

http://cnsnews.com/news/article/cbo-jobs-created-and-saved-stimulus-cost-minimum-average-228055-each

http://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/20160304

 

http://rricketts.ba.ttu.edu/Tax%20Rates%20and%20Revenues.htm

Republican Myth Busted: Reagan Raised the Debt Ceiling 3 Times More than Obama

http://www.dol.gov/newsroom/releases/20160304

 

https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/tax-reform/news/2011/06/27/9856/rich-peoples-taxes-have-little-to-do-with-job-creation/

https://www.americanprogress.org/issues/tax-reform/news/2011/06/20/9841/the-myth-of-the-lower-marginal-tax-rates/